Underwriting
What lenders actually look at on a butcher shop’s bank statements
- Published
- Reading time
- 8 minutes
- Written by
- MMC Underwriting Desk
For most non-bank funding, six months of business bank statements matter more than your tax return, your credit score and your business plan combined. The return is a year old and tells the underwriter what happened. The statements tell them what is happening. Here is what is actually being read, roughly in the order an underwriter reads it.
1. Average daily balance
The first number pulled is what you typically hold in the account, averaged across each day rather than measured at month end. This is the single best predictor of whether you can absorb a payment, and month-end snapshots are easy to dress up, which is why the daily average is used instead.
A shop turning $900,000 a year with an average daily balance of $4,000 is running on fumes regardless of what the profit and loss says. The same shop at $38,000 has a cushion. Both may be equally profitable; they are not equally financeable.
2. Negative days and NSF activity
The count of days the account ended negative, and the number of insufficient-funds or overdraft items. This is the most common single reason for a decline in short-term funding.
| Negative days in 6 months | Typical reading |
|---|---|
| 0 – 2 | Clean. No issue. |
| 3 – 5 | Acceptable to most lenders, may narrow terms slightly |
| 6 – 10 | Approval narrows considerably; expect higher pricing |
| 11 – 15 | Most short-term lenders decline; a few will look with strong offsetting factors |
| 16+ | Decline across effectively the whole market |
Pattern matters as much as count. Five negative days clustered in one bad week after a failed cooler reads very differently from five spread evenly across six months, which suggests the account simply operates near zero.
3. Deposit consistency and count
Not just total deposits, but how many and how regular. A retail butcher shop should show daily deposits at roughly consistent amounts with predictable weekly rhythm — Saturday heavy, Monday light. A wholesale processor shows fewer, larger deposits clustered around customer payment cycles.
What draws attention is a mismatch between the stated business model and the deposit pattern. A shop describing itself as pure retail, showing four deposits a month, invites a question. It usually has a perfectly good answer — the owner batches cash deposits weekly — but it will be asked, and having the answer ready shortens the process.
4. Existing debits, and who is taking them
An underwriter scans for regular fixed debits, particularly daily or weekly ACH withdrawals of consistent amounts — the signature of an existing merchant cash advance. Finding one changes the file entirely, and finding two or three usually ends it.
Do not omit these. They are visible in the statements you are submitting, and an application that fails to disclose a position the underwriter can see in front of them raises a credibility question far more damaging than the debt itself.
5. Seasonality, read against your industry
This is where a specialist underwriter and a generalist diverge sharply. A butcher shop whose deposits drop 40 percent in January is normal. A custom processor whose volume triples from September through December and falls away in spring is normal. A halal distributor with an enormous spike around Eid is normal.
A generalist underwriter sees a 40 percent revenue decline and reads distress. Which six months you submit can therefore change the outcome materially — and if your statements straddle a seasonal trough, say so in writing rather than hoping it is understood.
6. Transfers between accounts
Money moving between your own accounts is not revenue, and underwriters strip it out. Shops that move funds between operating, payroll and savings accounts frequently show inflated gross deposits that get discounted during review. The approval comes back smaller than expected and the reason is rarely explained.
If you run multiple accounts, label the transfers. It costs you nothing and it stops your deposit figure being cut by an underwriter making a conservative assumption in your absence.
What to do before you apply
- Pull your own last six months and count the negative days. If the number is above five, consider waiting two months and fixing it first — that alone can move both approval and pricing.
- Keep a buffer in the operating account. Average daily balance is a lever you can move deliberately, and it is read on every file.
- Consolidate revenue into one account, or disclose the split clearly at application.
- Label inter-account transfers so they are not counted as revenue and then stripped.
- Write one paragraph explaining anything unusual — a seasonal trough, an equipment failure, a one-off large deposit. Underwriters are not hostile; they are filling gaps with assumptions, and your paragraph replaces the assumption with a fact.
- Disclose every existing advance or loan. They can see it anyway.
The shops that get the best terms are not always the most profitable ones. They are the ones whose statements make the business legible in ten minutes. That is a presentation problem as much as a financial one, and unlike your margin, it can be fixed before Friday.